Case 01 · Leadership
Bottlenecked Leaders - FRC 8729
This case study explores how a robotics team was bottlenecked by leadership challenges.
- Role
- Author
- Team
- FRC 8729
- Timeline
- Jan – Aug 2026
- Published
Executive Summary
Since 2022, the robotics team 8729 has had large success in creating a legacy where students empower other students, building robots that became highly competitive without tanking the losses of graduating members. However, this legacy has broken cleanly with all of the junior year Rebuilt leads leaving after applying for lead for the 2027 season. This report investigates the factors and stories that could have led to this situation. It identifies problems with the work distribution, organisational culture, and the true meaning of leadership at this club.
This case is solely focused on the software subteam for the Rebuilt season, as it was the subteam with the most issues. The hardware subteam may share some issues that need the same attention.
The main problems identified in the 8729 organisation during the Rebuilt year are:
- the lack of beginner incentive,
- the poor coordination between leads and lesser-experienced members,
- and the implications as a leader.
The authors have investigated and critically analysed each main problem and provided adaptable solutions towards these problems. To understand the problems and consider solutions, this report applies theories including Organizational Culture Theory (OCT), Leader-Member Exchange Theory (LMX), Role Theory (RT), and Job Characteristics Model (JCM), alongside personal commentary from real members to analyse the signs of poor leadership. The author assumes that the mentors and leads are willing and capable of fostering a leadership that works for the team, not solely for the leads.
Problem Identification and Analysis
1. Work Distribution
- Work Distribution on-the-fly
- The dynamic that everything has to work for the leader in charge.
- There were many preventable mistakes if a plan with standards was updated and referencable. [1]
- Gap between what was taught vs what was used
- People coded, but testing and fixing was mainly handled by leads
- Major changes were being made more frequently than new members could grasp and understand. [1]
2. Organisational Culture
- Members do boilerplate, base code
- Leads test, fine-tune without member presence [2]
- No learning is gained from finishing an experience without testing/reflection.
- Leads and experienced members do all the testing without commentary
- Friction every time a member misses a meeting, obligatory or not. [1]
3. The True Meaning of Leadership
- The hardest thing about being a father is not learning how to care for somebody, it's learning how to quit thinking so much about yourself. -Julius Rock
- When leading a team, don’t take opportunity away from members. Actively provide it to them.
Generation and Evaluation of Alternate Solutions
Ensure members actually have tasks to learn from.
- They need feedback, an area to learn from mistakes.
- Problem Before: All issues were resolved by leads before put into the main code. The new members learned nothing from this.
- Resolution: Allow members to test out their code and fix the errors. This is a slow but exponential return on investment.
- Better communication
- Problem Before: Working on an entire robot’s code mostly by yourself is a very daunting task. Leaving no documentation about why a fix works or put them in a place dedicated to logs isolates you from others.
- Resolution: Provide commentary.
Leaders that take opportunity away from members are bottlenecked leaders.
Outcome
The departure of many members sprouted from the lack of opportunity and engagement. Quality control actually suppressed teamwork and what was once a collaborative environment became a rigid, hierarchical structure.
What I'd do differently
Ultimately, this case study reviews the problems and solutions that happen to motivated Robotics learners. The recommendations provided amplify the success of a motivated student’s willingness to learn. In conclusion, to build a community, you must support it..
References
To be added...